Well, the answer is obvios, since your on a Shenmue forum. Anyway, I can't really judge between the two--it's like apples and oranges--both are different , and both taste good.
Remember the good ole' days of this game? The time of thieves and cheaters--lol.
So what was your character's name? Was you a thief or a cheater? Or both? Any interesting stories about the times you had online with this game? Was you member of a clan? Come on, lets reminisce.