by OL » Fri Apr 03, 2009 12:18 am
Shenmue is not an RPG.
It's an adventure game. The only reason for the RPG push in Shenmue's advertising was because RPGs are by a wide margin the biggest gaming genre in Japan. If you look at the advertising for almost any game in Japan, they always laud the games as RPGs. Even things like Devil May Cry were touted as RPG-like because of the ability to improve Dante's move list. And DMC is quite obviously not an RPG.
It's just an attempt to sell more copies.
The ONLY RPG-like feature in Shenmue is the ability to improve the effectiveness of each particular move by monotonously performing it over and over again. Besides that? The game is an action-adventure, with an emphasis on the adventure part.
And yes, Shenmue has far more in common with Monkey Island than it does with Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest, Elder Scrolls, or Fallout.
Don't question someone's ability to see a "deeper picture" when it's you who is perceiving things incorrectly.