KidMarine wrote: Maybe they should just jettison modern Sonic altogether and concentrate on the Sonic that people actually like?
Definately not, Sonic can't live in the past forever. There are a lot of people, including me, that like Modern Sonic and the 3D games that go along with him and want to see a new game with a more serious tone. Not as serious as Sonic 06, but definately not as silly as Lost World. To me the Adventures set the benchmark of how a story can go.
I love the classics but the 3D games can give a whole different sensation of speed and fun. I see no reason why they should go. The Adventures were great, Generations was great and so were Sonics stages in Unleashed.