Amir wrote: I can understand and live with 4:3 for Shenmue I cutscenes, it's just the 16:9 letterboxed ones for Shenmue II with the double black bars that have me worried. If they get this and shadows sorted out for Shenmue II I'll be a happy man.
The trailer didn't have double black bars for the Shenmue Tree cutscene. I'm assuming/hoping it's selectable in 2.
That being said, I realized there's an easy way for them to address the very few scenes in 1 that don't work out while expanded to 16x9. Just do the same thing that TV shows like the X-Files did when the first 4 seasons which were originally 4x3 got remastered for 16x9. When the footage didn't allow them to gain additional detail on the sides, they zoomed in. This is far easier than actually editing the cutscene, and it's easy enough that we could do it on Dreamcast as a proof of concept via cheat device codes. Just need to check for the proper event ID's and change the camera parameters as necessary. In the examples I've seen there are no face close ups, so if you're zooming against the top everything still looks good. Tweaking character positions is risky, but editing the camera when necessary isn't a big deal IMO.
I'd prefer 16x9 all around, and for people who want 4x3 they can have that option too. They're probably too far into this to consider that feedback, but who knows. I was planning to reach out to them anyway, guess I can add this to my list.