I just finished the game too. Well Yama took the words out of my mouth. The acting was a step up from Heavy Rain, especially in regards to William Dafoe who fit his role perfectly. He stole the show for me.
The controls while yes were clunky at times and had no type of hud or directional assist, to me im fine without it in favor of the more cinematic feel.
And wow was the game just the epitome of how to make you feel like you are playing a movie. Almost, just almost to the point you regret not having more control over your character but enough to the point where you can still call it a game and make mistakes.
The soundtrack was also very good. Like The Last of Us, it enhanced the story telling. Although still, The Last of Us was better in virtually all aspects besides maybe graphics. My PS3 was working hard as fuhh while playing this. Honestly id replay it right now but I dont want to tax my PS3 so hard again.
Overall I give it a solid 4/5.